Jaye P. Morgan
How a school treasurer became a Fifties chart name
Mary Margaret Morgan took her stage name from a famous banker, and climbed from school assemblies to the Billboard top three.
Mary Margaret Morgan was born on 3 December 1931 in Mancos, a small place in southwestern Colorado, one of seven children. Her family moved to California, and at Verdugo Hills High School in Los Angeles she served as class treasurer. That job earned her the nickname Jaye P., a joke on the banker J. P. Morgan. She sang at school assemblies, accompanied by her brother on guitar, and the nickname turned into a professional name.
The breakthrough came in 1953, when Derby Records issued her version of “Life Is Just a Bowl of Cherries”, which reached number 26 on the Billboard chart. An RCA Victor contract followed, and in a single year she had five hits. The biggest was “That’s All I Want from You”, which climbed to number three. Others included “The Longest Walk” and “Pepper Hot Baby”. After six years at RCA Victor she moved to MGM Records in 1959, and in late 1955 the British magazine NME reported that she topped the American Cash Box poll for female vocalists.
Television made her a familiar face. She sang on the series Stop the Music, appeared on the Robert Q. Lewis show on CBS, and in 1956 had a program of her own. Over the following years she turned up in variety programs, anthology dramas and sitcoms. In 1978 she appeared on The Muppet Show, singing “That Old Black Magic” as a duet with Dr. Teeth, and she made numerous visits to The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson.
Through the 1960s and 1970s she kept working nightclubs, and later she returned to film in supporting roles, also becoming known as a game show panelist. “Keepin’ It to Myself” is a reminder that the singing never fully stopped. She died on 24 August 2026, leaving a career that ran from the era of the pop single to the age of the talk-show couch.
On Coast Ibiza
Songs by Jaye P. Morgan in the Coast Ibiza playlist:
Keepin' It to Myself1976
This story is based on the Wikipedia article “Jaye P. Morgan” and is shared under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 licence. Read the Wikipedia article.
