The Buoys
The song written to be banned, and the band that recorded it
A pop group from Pennsylvania recorded a cannibalism song on purpose, and then found a bigger audience in Europe with a bank robber ballad.

Rupert Holmes wrote “Timothy” with one aim: to get it banned. The theme was cannibalism. He picked The Buoys, a pop and rock band from the Wilkes-Barre-Scranton area of Pennsylvania, to record it. Bill Kelly, Fran Brozena, Jerry Hludzik, Carl Siracuse and Chris Hanlon were the members. They had signed to Scepter Records, which had until then ignored them, and the single came out in December 1970. It reached number 17 in the United States in 1971.
The label only worked out what the song was about once it began climbing the charts. Executives then claimed that Timothy was a mule, but Holmes rejected the attempt. He had meant to offend. He also told a journalist that he learned of a 1963 mine disaster in Sheppton, Pennsylvania only after the song charted, and that he might never have written it had he known.
Holmes and D. Jordan wrote the follow-up, “Give Up Your Guns”, in 1972. It is an epic narrative about an escaped bank robber and much more serious in tone. It reached only number 84 in the United States, yet it became a massive hit twice in mainland Europe, once on release and again in 1979. Holmes wrote more songs for the band, among them “The Prince of Thieves”, “Bloodknot” and “Tomorrow”, which were all complaints from criminals.
The band’s own writing sounded different. They blended harmonies in the manner of Crosby, Stills and Nash with piano, strings, brass and harp, drawing on 1950s rock and roll, 1960s protest songs, 1930s-style pop and Renaissance-flavoured prog. Kelly and Hludzik later formed the Jerry-Kelly Band, then Dakota, who opened for Queen on a sold-out tour. Holmes would go on to write Broadway musicals. Kelly died in Nashville on December 13, 2024, at the age of 74.
On Coast Ibiza
Songs by The Buoys in the Coast Ibiza playlist:
Give Up Your Guns1971
This story is based on the Wikipedia article “The Buoys (American band)” and is shared under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 licence. Read the Wikipedia article.
